Physiological and Cultural Adaptations to High Solar Radiation.
I chose the environmental stress of “high levels of solar radiation” and its effects on those living in conditions of extreme exposure. Geographic locations affected by extreme solar radiation aren't necessarily limited to warm climates. Although extremely hot environments can be a sign of high solar radiation levels, high altitudes and atmospheric conditions with less cloud coverage, as well as constant exposure to the sun, can also be factors. The negative effects of living in these environments consist of electrolyte and water imbalances, which cause heat stroke and dehydration, leading to low levels of energy and, in more extreme cases, death. Organ functionality can be negatively impacted, as organs such as the heart and brain may fail to receive enough oxygen carried through the bloodstream due to the overexertion of energy used to cool the body and conserve water. Vitamin B9 (folate) can also be broken down in the bloodstream, which slows the building of red blood cells and the process of DNA synthesis, leading to birth defects in children as well as negative health effects in the mothers. Humans living in these conditions would be a high risk for developing skin cancers such as melanoma and other damage to DNA and skin barriers as well if it were not for the type of melanin called eumelanin that is found in those of African descent and is darker compared to pheomelanin which is seen mostly in those with a lighter complexion. The eumelanin acts as a skin barrier for the UV rays caused by solar radiation, which otherwise would burn the epidermis as well as the dermis layer of the skin.
(Long-term average of global solar radiation.)
As mentioned, there have been many adaptations to protect the physiological functionality of people living in high solar and UV radiation zones:
Short-term adaptations-Sweat Glands:
Short term adaptations found in those exposed to these extreme conditions consist of releasing perspiration from sweat glands to cool the external body temperature as well as the temporary thickening of the epidermis which can thicken within 4-5 days following exposure to high solar radiation, and can grow gradually thicker over weeks, but will revert to its original thickness after a month of less exposure and following the turnover of epidermis skin cells. Both of these adaptations can be of varying levels, in less extreme cases they exist within the environment of high solar and uv radiation but will dissipate once removed from this environment, however, like most effects of extreme climates, there are levels and too much exposure especially to non-natives to the climate may observe extreme sweating and sun poisoning, which is still temporary but should be looked into by a medical professional.
Facultative adaptations- Vasodilation:
Vasodilation, where red blood cells will expand to release more blood flow closer to the surface of the skin, where the internal heat can be transferred externally through convection and radiation, also bringing cooler blood vessels into the body's bloodstream. This is a facultative adaptation because while the individual's DNA does not permanently alter to display this physical change, the temporary gene expression to control nitric oxide is activated, however it will revert to its normal homeostasis once removed from this condition after several weeks, no genes are permanently altered, only expressed differently in the conditions.
Developmental adaptations-Limb structures:
An interesting developmental Adaptation to those living in parts of East Africa, specifically the Masai tribe, is seen in their long, slender limbs, which allow for greater surface area for heat dispersion and blood circulation. This is a trait seen in many places of high solar radiation, which is greatly concentrated in the African Continent. Longer arms and legs assist with losing body heat quickly in the high temperatures. This is a genetic trait which is still observed in parts of the Middle East as well as Africa, which are rather arid with low latitude, allowing for the penetration of more impactful solar radiation.
Cultural adaptations-Architectural Functionality:
The architectural style of the people of the Maasai tribe of East Africa conserves cool air by organizing the placement of housing to provide the most shade within villages, as well as constructing houses out of small rounded windows and use cow dung (this is very common and should not be written off as unsanitary), sticks and mud to thicken walls enough to preserve the coolair that enters the house in the evening. Culturally, every couple of months, those living in these communities will “replaster” their walls and floor with a fresh layer of mud and cow dung, which is cleaned and allows for proper insulation. Overhangs and windows on these homes and buildings allow for sun avoidance during the peak hottest hours of the day, facing away from the sun.
What are the benefits of studying human variation?
There are several benefits of studying the variation of the human species regarding their geographical location and the extreme climate conditions they endure. This includes learning what internal and external adaptations prevent illnesses and overexertion in these particular environments, such as overexposure to solar radiation. It is important to know what the causes of physical differences are and why some societies seem to thrive in particular environments more than others because, just as it is important for those with thick skin barriers to have adequate exposure to sun to absorb enough vitamin D (which otherwise would have to be supplemented with within the diet such as in polynesian cultures), it is important for those with weaker skin barriers and less melanin to protect themselves from the sun with spf or shade.
Can race explain these adaptations?
While it is easy to assume that those within a race have a specific ancestral genetic lineage that relates to their personal set of adaptations, most of how they have adapted to their given climates, in any case of the extremes, is due to their location, not necessarily their race. The term “race” can be used to lump together people of a specific background; however, it has been seen on many occasions to be the case where differing “races” in neighboring regions of similar extreme climates have developed the same adaptations. An example of this would be the development of more surface area on the lips of a person having which ability an individual to cool faster in warm climates and climates of increased solar radiation. This is seen in people of African descent. Middle Eastern and Polynesian descent, all of whom experience high levels of sun exposure and have adapted genetically to form a similar (but not the same) facial feature.
While these differing cultures of course have a very distant ancestor, their adaptations are analogous, making them the same through environmental factors, but not genetically predetermined factors. Environmental influences are a more reliable way in which to determine and understand the causes and effects that the climate and environment one lives in have shaped their internal and external facets. In this way, we can find the similarities in races without creating a subconscious division between them as all humans stem from a common ancestor, who, while their offspring evolved to their migrated-to environments, diverged only in ways that would give them their best shot at survival.
Hello! First of all, I never would have thought longer limbs would be an affective developmental adaptation to high solar radiation. Very interesting. Secondly, I'm certain those houses in the Maasai tribe in East Africa are very cool on the inside, but I'm guessing if they are bonded with cow dung they probably have a particular odor in the summer time. Third, I would just like to say I very much enjoyed that you chose High Solar Radiation as your theme. I chose High Altitude Radiation and I'm guessing that is going to be pretty common. Good Job!
ReplyDeleteInitial comment: You chose solar radiation stress, but most of your post discussed heat stress. You would have been better off just sticking with heat stress for your discussion.
ReplyDelete1. Describe stress (/5) - So while heat stress and solar radiation stress can occur simultaneously, if you choose solar radiation stress, discussing the impact of heat stress doesn't help your reader understand solar radiation stress. You should have kept your focus there.
Beyond that, you did a good job of addressing the problems with solar radiation stress, but solar radiation is unique among the four stresses in this assignment in that we actually *need* solar radiation for positive reasons, namely for Vitamin D absorption. Vitamin D is called the "sunshine vitamin" for a reason! It needs the sun to be correctly incorporate into our body and Vitamin D is important for bone production/repair/health. This complicates the way our body responds to solar radiation stress, because any adaptation can't negatively impact Vitamin D absorption.
2. Adaptations
a. Short term (2/5) - Sweating is an adaptation heat stress, not solar radiation stress. There actually is no short term adaptation to solar radiation which is why it is such a dangerous stress. What you are describing here is a facultative adaptation, not short term.
b. Facultative (2/5) - Again, since you chose solar radiation stress, that is where you needed to focus with regard to adaptations. A facultative adaptation to solar radiation is tanning.
c. Long term (3/5) - The adaptation you are identifying here is to heat stress. Not solar radiation. A long term adaptation to solar radiation stress is a higher level of base melanin in the skin, not through tanning but in terms of the genetic skin color they are born with. It is also important to discuss here the balance between protecting the body from solar radiation and making sure we still receive enough of the "good" radiation to allow for Vitamin D absorption.
d. Cultural (3/5) - Again, you discuss heat stress, not solar radiation stress. A little more leeway here since shelter is also an adaptation to solar radiation stress, but that needed to be discussed here.
3. Benefits (5/5) - Good.
4. Racism (8/10) - "Environmental influences are a more reliable way in which to determine and understand the causes and effects that the climate"
It isn't just an issue of it being "more reliable". Race isn't really reliable at all. A lot of what you offer here in this last section kind of dances around the conclusion here. On the right track. Just needed to nail down the actual issue here of the question of a "causal relationship". Here's the way to think about it:
To answer this question, you first need to explore what race actually is. Race is not based in biology but is a social construct, based in beliefs and preconceptions, and used only to categorize humans into groups based upon external physical features, much like organizing a box of crayons by color. Race does not *cause* adaptations like environmental stress does, and without that causal relationship, you can't use race to explain adaptations. Race has no explanatory value over human variation.
That first prompt should have read "1. Describe stress (4/5)"
DeleteHello Alicia,
ReplyDeleteYour summary of the stresses of high levels of solar radiation was quite informative. I find eumelanin as an evolutionary answer to be very interesting, it is incredibly beneficial at shielding some humans from an array of nasty side effects of the sun. Before this week I had never heard of the thickening of skin during exposure to excessive solar radiation, the short amount of time it takes is incredible. The natural ability of some of these groups of people to regulate heat mixed with their genetically longer limbs seem to have lent to budding hotbeds for professional North American sports teams looking for talent, as there are many new camps and schools being opened in these areas of high solar radiation across the globe to develop their talents.
Hi, Alicia! I really enjoyed your discussion on high solar radiation adaptations. I covered high-altitude environments, but I found this very interesting too. It is super interesting how solar radiation can impact folate breakdown and organ function. Living in southern California, I’ve only ever thought of solar radiation symptoms as sunburns and heat strokes! I think it’s so interesting how the Maasai use natural materials to form sustainable insulation that’s effective in extreme heat. It illustrates how intuitive humans are in extreme environments and how deeply connected architecture can be to the environment. Excellent job!
ReplyDelete